I’m very aware that the “chocolate with mint” camp is a divided one. On the one side, there are those who treasure the combination of rich chocolate with refreshingly herbaceous mint and leap at the opportunity to lick mint chocolate chip ice cream or crunch on a Girl Scout Cookie Thin Mint. On the other side, there are those who believe mint should be reserved for things like toothpaste and gum—adding the fragrant herb is simply not something they cannot get behind.
That said, while these chocolate peppermint cookies are mainly for those who appreciate the flavor combination, I think naysayers would be pleasantly surprised with the subtly of the peppermint as a complement to this cookie’s rich chocolate flavor.
With melted bittersweet chocolate in the batter, along with chocolate chips, followed by chocolate drizzle on top, these cookies do not lack chocolate. There is just a dash of peppermint extract in the batter (which could actually be omitted) and festive candy cane crumbles on top resulting in just enough peppermint essence to give you a cooling freshness between bites of chocolate, but not too much to be overpowering.
These chocolate peppermint cookies keep well in the freezer (fully baked, sealed tightly, for up to 3 weeks); making them a perfect option for baking ahead around the holidays. They also look beautiful on a holiday dessert table—you may even see your uncle who hates chocolate and mint together grabbing for one.
More for your chocolate lovers: